| This approach usually includes a meal plan, portion control, dietary prescription or manipulation, a prescription of exercise, counselling in behavioural modification techniques, and encouragement. This approach relies on external controls. With this approach you can expect: weight loss and improvement of biochemical markers during first 12 weeks with likely weight regain to your original weight within 3-5 years. Biochemical markers may also revert to pre-treatment levels. | The Intuitive Eating approach encourages and enables healthy behaviours regardless of current weight status or body shape. This approach usually includes training in mindful eating, training in hunger-fullness awareness, experimentation with responding to body cues, pursuit of joyful movement, exploration of dieting history and reframing the value of body weight and shape, psychological support and encouragement. |
| Main focus: Intention of treatment is to achieve body weight loss or body shape change. The traditional approach to health/weight management focuses heavily on weight and a number on a scale. | Main focus: The Intuitive Eating Approach is a multi-faceted approach that focuses on improved health. No stipulation of appropriate serving/portion sizes or eating times. Development of hunger/fullness awareness and familiarity, development of skills in mindful eating, building of trust in one’s body cues. |
| Evidence: □ Research has taught us that 80% of people who lose weight go on to regain that lost weight at 5 years of commencing a diet, and that the probability of achieving a BMI< 25kg/m2 (if currently classified as Obese) is 1 in 124 for women and 1 in 210 for men; □ Weight cycling occurs in 1/3 of all participants who undertake restrictive dieting practices; □ Being unfit is more of a predictor for mortality than weight; □ Healthy behaviours, like the following are more important to your health than weight: Core foods (5+ Fruit and veg), > 12 x month leisure time physical activity, not smoking, >0 and up to 1 alcoholic drink per day for women and 2 for men. | Evidence: □ Research confirms you can expect long term weight stability at 5 years after possible initial weight fluctuation. Possible improvement in blood pressure, cholesterol, blood sugar, cortisol level. □ Likely improvement in intuitive eating behaviours and diet quality, reduced body dissatisfaction, sustained physical activities; and reduced morbidity and mortality risk. □ Improvements in dietary quality, improved psychological health, decrease in disordered eating patterns and behaviours, improved self-esteem and lower risk of depression. |
| Risks associated with the traditional approach to weight management: □ Development of disordered or maladaptive eating patterns (binge eating, or strict dietary restriction), □ Chronic dieting syndrome, including weight cycling; □ Increased risk of depression, anxiety, impairment of working memory impairment; □ Increased risk of morbidity and mortality; □ Increased weight from baseline | Risks associated with the intuitive eating approach: □ Lack of support from family/friends due to their unfamiliarity with approach; □ Initial unease with letting go of long-held dietary beliefs □ Grief due to loss of ‘thin me’ dream. |